11+ appeals and reviews: how they work and how to prepare

How grammar school reviews and appeals work, the deadlines, what evidence helps, and what to expect at a hearing.

Updated · 5 min read · By the Fair Eleven team

If your child narrowly missed the qualifying score, or qualified but was not offered a place, you may still have options. There are two different routes: a local review, which some areas run before places are offered, and a formal appeal, which every family can make after National Offer Day. The details differ between areas, so always read your local authority's guidance alongside this overview.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. In England, appeals must follow the School Admission Appeals Code (2022). Your local authority and the school's admissions pages are the official sources for your area.

Local reviews before offers

Some grammar school areas run a local review to decide whether a child who did not reach the qualifying score should still be treated as being of grammar school standard. The Appeals Code says any review must be finished before places are allocated, and that it does not replace your right of appeal.

  • Kent: the headteacher assessment. Your child's primary headteacher can refer them to a panel of local headteachers before results are sent out. The panel looks at evidence such as recent school work and the unmarked writing exercise. Parents do not apply directly, so talk to your child's headteacher early.
  • Buckinghamshire: the Selection Review. Parents request it through the council after results arrive, with a tight deadline and a summary sheet completed by the headteacher. Check Buckinghamshire Council's Selection Review page for the current dates.
  • Other areas: many have no review stage at all. Check your area's admissions guidance as soon as results arrive.

There is no re-mark of the Kent Test. If your child was not assessed suitable, you can still name a Kent grammar school on your application; it will be refused on National Offer Day, and you can then appeal.

Appeals after National Offer Day

If you named a school on your application and were refused a place, you have the legal right to appeal to an independent panel. The admission authority must:

  • publish its appeals timetable on its website by 28 February;
  • give you at least 20 school days from the date you were told your application was unsuccessful to lodge your appeal;
  • give you at least 10 school days' notice of the hearing;
  • hear appeals lodged on time within 40 school days of the lodging deadline.

The panel's decision letter should be sent within five school days of the hearing.

How grammar school appeal panels decide

For grammar schools, what the panel considers depends on whether your area ran a local review:

  1. No local review: the panel can only uphold the appeal if there is evidence that your child is of the required academic standard, and, where the school is full, your case for a place outweighs the problems an extra pupil would cause the school.
  2. A local review was held: the panel looks at whether your child's review was carried out in a fair, consistent and objective way. If there is no evidence that it was, the panel looks at the academic evidence as above.

The panel must not set its own test or invent its own way of judging ability. It works only from the evidence in front of it. If your child did qualify but the school is full, the panel checks that the admission rules were lawful and applied correctly, then weighs your reasons against the impact on the school.

Evidence that can help

  • School reports and current attainment from the primary school. The Appeals Code gives Year 5 and Year 6 results as an example.
  • A letter from your child's current or previous school (for example the headteacher or class teacher) clearly explaining why your child is considered to be of grammar school ability.
  • Evidence of circumstances on test day, such as illness or a bereavement, documented at the time.
  • For a full school, specific reasons why that school suits your child in a way your allocated school does not.

Mock results from home or private providers, including ours, usually carry little weight on their own, because panels cannot check the conditions they were sat in. Staff from the school you are appealing for are not allowed to support individual appeals, so your evidence should come from your child's own school.

At the hearing

Hearings are usually short and less formal than people expect. They may be held in person or by video. You can speak at the hearing, and you can be represented or accompanied by a friend; the admission authority will ask beforehand whether you plan to be represented. Send any extra evidence by the deadline in your hearing letter, as late evidence might not be considered. Prepare a clear, brief summary of your case, bring copies of your evidence, and focus on facts rather than how disappointed you feel.

Waiting lists

You can appeal and stay on a school's waiting list at the same time. Oversubscribed schools must keep a waiting list until at least 31 December of the year your child starts, ranked by their admission rules, not by when you joined. Accept the place you were offered while you wait, so your child is not left without one.

Whatever happens

The 11+ is one path, and every path is a good path. Our wellbeing hub has ideas for talking to your child about results, whatever they are. For the wider timetable, see our guide to secondary school application dates.

Sources: School Admission Appeals Code 2022 (GOV.UK), School Admissions Code 2021 (GOV.UK), Kent County Council: Kent Test results, Buckinghamshire Council: Selection Review. Checked November 2026. Always confirm dates with the school or local authority.

Frequently asked questions

Can I appeal if my child did not pass the 11+?

Yes, as long as you named the grammar school on your secondary school application and were refused a place. The panel will need evidence that your child is of the required academic standard, such as school reports and a letter from the headteacher.

What is the deadline for a grammar school appeal?

You must be given at least 20 school days from the date you were told your application was unsuccessful. Your local authority or the school will give the exact date, and must publish its appeals timetable by 28 February.

When will my appeal be heard?

Appeals lodged on time in the normal round must be heard within 40 school days of the deadline for lodging appeals, and you must get at least 10 school days' notice of the hearing.

Can the appeal panel test my child again?

No. The panel must not set its own test or devise its own way of judging ability. It decides from the evidence provided, so send clear school evidence by the deadline.

Do private mock results help an 11+ appeal?

Usually only a little, because panels cannot verify the conditions. School reports and a headteacher's letter normally carry more weight.

Is there a re-mark of the Kent Test?

No. In Kent the route is the headteacher assessment before results, and then an appeal after National Offer Day if you are refused a place.

Find out where your child stands

Realistic Kent and Bucks 11+ mocks to print at home, marked instantly online with a topic report, and worked solutions for every question. Buy once and keep it, or start with our free mini-mock.